We have covered some essential points. For full info, check out the sources listed. Without further ado, let’s dive in.

1. The New Search Landscape

  • According to Ahrefs’ September 2025 data, Google still holds 90.4% of global search share.

  • But in AI assistants, ChatGPT commands 81.13%, followed by Perplexity (10.82 %), Copilot (4.05 %) and Gemini (2.82 %).

  • Stox quoted Ahrefs’ Ryan Law: “Google still sends far more traffic … AI search does not replace traditional search; it extends it.”

What it means:
The world is becoming dual-layered. Traditional search (Google, Bing, etc.) remains central, but a parallel layer of discovery is now emerging via AI assistants.

SEO impact:
You can no longer optimize only for Google. You also need to appear in AI assistant outputs and be citable by those models.

How to prepare (SEO pros):

  • Track both traditional organic traffic and AI referral/citation presence (if tools allow).

  • Maintain strong core SEO (technical, content, links) to retain Google visibility.

  • Simultaneously invest in making your content “AI-friendly” (clear, structured, referenceable) so it’s more likely to be surfaced by assistants.

2. AI Traffic Growth Is Explosive

  • Ahrefs’ Web Analytics (82,000 sites) shows AI-generated traffic has increased ~9.7× year-over-year.

  • The trendline in Ahrefs’ visualizations heavily favours referrals from ChatGPT over other assistants.

What it means:
Users are increasingly turning to AI assistants rather than classic search interfaces to get information, recommendations, or answers.

SEO impact:
A growing share of your potential audience may come via AI systems, meaning only following traditional tactics could yield diminishing returns.

How to prepare:

  • Audit your existing content: which pages are most likely to be cited (data, studies, definitive explainers).

  • Prioritize content that answers direct questions, provides unique insight, or can be cited as a reference.

  • Monitor and experiment with featured snippets, structured data, and FAQ blocks; they may help content be surfaced in AI summaries.

3. The “Great Decoupling”

  • In analyses of ~800,000 Google Search Console properties, impressions are increasing, but clicks are declining.

  • AI Overviews (generative summaries) now appear in ~19% of SERPs.

  • In March 2025, average CTR for position #1 dropped by 34.5%.

  • Stox projected that clicks could shrink to 25% of their former levels.

What it means:
As AI summaries become widespread, users often get answers directly without clicking through to sites. The traditional “clicks = engagement” model weakens.

SEO impact:
Relying purely on click volume (and CTR) as success metrics will become misleading. Impressions, visibility in AI contexts, and conversions matter more than ever.

How to prepare:

  • Begin tracking impressions, coverage, mentions in AI outputs/summaries, not just clicks.

  • Focus on conversion and engagement metrics (time on page, scroll depth, lead generation) as stronger indicators of value.

  • Ensure pages are optimized for snippet format, with clear answer blocks, structured data, and well-formatted content that’s easily “digestible” by AI.

Subscribe to keep reading

This content is free, but you must be subscribed to The Citation Cult to continue reading.

Already a subscriber?Sign in.Not now

Reply

or to participate

Keep Reading

No posts found